Dear Editor:
Re: A Tale of Two Schools
I was astonished by Claudia Wallis’ inaccurate portrayal of Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) and the work of teachers and students at Alpine Learning Group (“A Tale of Two Schools,” TIME, May 15, 2006). Wallis spent hours at Alpine, reviewing the scientific research supporting ABA and observing our happy, related students engaged in learning activities guided by our dedicated and enthusiastic staff.
Errors of detail aside, Wallis missed the most salient facts for parents facing the momentous choices regarding their child’s treatment. ABA is the only intervention for autism supported by peer-reviewed scientific studies. Properly implemented by well-trained therapists, ABA can help children with autism learn to talk, to read, to write, to relate to their peers, and to participate fully and productively in their families and communities. ABA is a science, and as behavior analysts we are accountable for every moment we spend with our students. At Alpine, students’ days are filled not only with laughter and fun, but with meaningful learning opportunities aimed at reaching each student’s full potential.
While it is disappointing that Wallis misapprehended the science of ABA, it is truly distressing that she misrepresented and undersold the accomplishments of Alpine’s phenomenal students, families, and teachers. Reducing science to a sound bite is unprofessional, but reducing our students’ courageous work to an inapt cliché is unforgivable.
Bridget A. Taylor, PsyD, BCBA
Executive Director
Alpine Learning Group
Guidelines for Submissions to the ASAT Forum
There are a number of internet forums that enable members of the public, both parents and professionals, to share their experiences surrounding the diagnosis, treatment and ongoing progress of a child with autism. The ASAT forum is another such venue; however, this forum will host contributions that reflect ASAT’s mission and guiding values:
ASAT’s mission:
“to disseminate accurate, scientifically sound information about autism and treatments for autism and to improve access to effective, science-based treatments for all people with autism, regardless of age, severity of condition, income or place of residence.”
ASAT’s guiding values:
“ASAT is committed to science as the most objective, time-tested and reliable approach to discerning between safe, effective autism treatments, and those that are harmful or ineffective. ASAT supports all scientifically sound research on the prevention, treatment and cure of autism, as well as all treatments for autism that are shown to be effective through solid scientific research, regardless of discipline or domain.”
Please note, however that the material selected to be placed on the forum represents the views of the individual authors of each selection, and does not necessarily represent a formal position taken by the Board of ASAT
